We avid readers of fiction all have our favorite authors. Some of us can narrow our faves to a list of a few, and maybe there are some of us who if pressed will concede our top-notch favorite author—but usually with a caveat of some kind to insure that the others on the list are so close to that single selection the margin is nearly immeasurable or possibly noting that this favorite is in a specific genre.
But even among favorite authors, we have our less favorite books in their offerings. You know those you couldn’t wait to buy, but when you finally got the time to read them, the anticipation level far exceeded the actual end result? (I should give inspirational credit here to Michael Snyder for his Thursday post at The Master’s Artist. Go read it if you haven’t simply because of the valid multiple points he makes with his unique brand of humor.)
Even those of us who’ve written a few novels seem to number their appeal to us. One or two stand out for various reasons: our attachment to the characters; our experience while writing it/them; the way the words worked just right; the resolution; the quirks; the overall appeal. Who knows?
One of my most favorite authors is the great Frank Peretti. I love Peretti’s writing. However, I did not particularly enjoy Monster. I could still appreciate his writing—the usual way he depicts characters, scenes, uses the senses, and makes me feel like I’m reading a movie—but I didn’t care for the plot, unique as it was, and I wasn’t in love with the characters. Even with the letdown of reading that novel, I can hardly wait until he releases a new one. And for Peretti fans that’s usually a long wait these days.
It seems when many writers look back on some of their novels, they see glaring weaknesses and insist they would’ve done things differently. That seems plausible for the first couple, but after a point in time, it does seem like a writer must come to terms with how he/she tells a story at any given time. If authors drastically change after a couple of novels, perhaps it’s because they really no longer like the style they’ve used and must develop another. Voice evolves, but does it really change? If so, why? Was it un-genuine to begin with? Borrowed? An imitation?
How do you think you arrived at your favorite authors and why’d you choose to eliminate one or two of their collective novels from your favorites?
God, we tend to choose favorites, but you treat us all as favorites since you are no respecter of persons. Thank you for that. In the Name of Jesus, Amen.