The timing is suspicious, the controversy intense, the questions abound, but here it is anyway, the second book by Harper Lee, Go Set A Watchman.
Let me skip over the supposed origin of the story and just take it at face value. To do that I must admit to being a youngster in the 50s, a "Yankee" or a "nothena" (northerner), specifically a daughter of the northwest. And naively oblivious to the troubles of the south and, frankly, to its history. My sheltered city life didn't teach me to subjugate any people. I can honestly say I did not consciously know prejudice. This simple fact of my upbringing makes it difficult and slightly unfair to critique this type of southern novel.
When I was in the fourth or fifth grade, I visited a friend. While she readied herself for whatever we planned to do, I happened to see the TV was on in the living room where I waited. I watched while a man took a brick to another man who happened to be black and beat him in the head with it. I almost vomited. This wasn't a newsreel, it was a drama of some kind. The sound effects were advanced because I never forgot the sound of that brick meeting a skull. If what I saw was about prejudice, I didn't realize it at the time, and I don't remember anything else about that day except the sound and sight of that beating.
So, Scout (Jean-Louise) Finch grows up and moves to New York and returns for a visit to the fictitious town of her birth in Alabama to visit her father (Atticus), his brother (Dr. Finch), sister (Alexandra), and her childhood companion and first love, Henry "Hank" Clinton. The trip begins well, although she wonders if she truly wants to have a romantic relationship with Hank even though he plans to marry her.
By this time, her dad's arthritis is advancing and he requires some assistance from his sister since their Negro housekeeper Calpurnia has since retired. Her aunt's odd situation has allowed her to move into Atticus' home. Life seems somewhat unchanged to Jean-Louise until she attends a town council meeting and is shocked to hear the guest speaker. At that point, everything she thought she knew about her upbringing, her father, Hank, and her aunt comes tumbling down around her, rattling her to the point of near hysteria.
She confronts her father with her ire in full force and is shocked at his response.
The story rocks back and forth from the present to the past memories from Scout's/Jean Louise's point of view, noting the similarities but concentrating on the differences from her childhood to her womanhood of 26 years. The contrast in her perceptions of her father and Hank drive her to an unlikely scene with her aunt and uncle which somehow placates her attitude and allows her to reconsider the emotional outburst which spewed her wrath at Hank first and then her beloved father.
Poisonous racism and the associated insidious attitudes of the south from both sides of the racial divide in that time period lie at the heart of this novel, so it's interesting - and rather suspicious - to consider the timing of the release of this novel. It feels as if there is a political underbelly to the controversy around this book coming into print after all these years.
The story is almost like a journal of Scout Finch's progress from her youth to a young woman, always rebellious to the process of becoming a "southern belle". An intentional misfit, a bit profane, not always likeable, she somewhat resents the town of her origin and its traditions, railing against the prejudices she failed to notice in her early life. The title, a rough reference to a biblical concept, suggests that mankind can "set" his conscience as a guard to corruption, but clearly mankind cannot always successfully do so.
Go Set A Watchman by Harper Lee will reflect some of those feelings experienced in the south during those racially-charged years, and, sadly, once again we see an attempt to resurrect them in our time.
Father, only you know the hearts of mankind, and only you can save our souls. Thank you that you even consider any of us worth saving. In the Name of Jesus, Amen.